Professionalism and Ethics Committee

Mission Statement
To enhance relations between policyholder counsel and insurer coverage counsel and strive for the highest professionalism and ethics among College Fellows.

2024-2025 Co-chairs

Seth Friedman
Seth Friedman
Partner
Lewis Brisbois Bisgaard
& Smith LLP
Neil Posner
Neil Posner
Chair, Policyholders’ Insurance
Coverage Practice Group
Much Shelist, P.C.


Contact: 
professionalethics @ americancollegecoverage.org

Committee News Articles

January 6, 2025

California Court Apps Recognizes Duty on Insurance Defense Counsel to Anticipate Impact of Settlement of Civil Suit on an Ongoing Criminal Case

An attorney retained by an insurer to represent an insured in a car wreck case is being sued for not anticipating a monetary restitution ruling in the companion criminal case. Here, the civil suit was settled for the policy limits and then the criminal case against the insured proceeded with the court ordering that the insured pay the claimant’s attorneys fees in the civil suit as restitution.

Even though it was not possible for the civil suit settlement to totally eliminate the insured's legal obligation to pay criminal restitution, the court found actionable the insured’s contention that the insurance defense attorney negligently drafted the settlement because he should have allocated between economic and non-economic damages to minimize the criminal restitution award holding:

We reject the suggestion that an attorney cannot be sued for malpractice with respect to matters outside the scope of his or her client contract or retainer agreement … Here, Go's allegations demonstrate his claims rely at least in part on an asserted duty within the scope of defendants' representation: to competently draft the settlement and release in the civil wrongful death action.


August 2018
Dealing with Claimant Requests for Information and Other Sources of Recovery

Selected Presentations and Papers

The Rise of Attorney Mistakes In Legal Malpractice Claims – Balancing Insurer Cost-Cutting and Billing Guidelines With the Lawyer’s Duties of Competence and Diligence
By Spencer Taylor

Insurance Defense Counsel Must Be Cautious in Sharing Information with the Insurer
By William Barker

Insurer Guidelines and Third Party Bill Reviews: Ethical and Practical Ramifications
By Douglas M. McIntosh, Neil Posner and James R. Sutterfield

Locking Others Out Of Your Confidential Communications With Coverage Counsel
By Dan D. Kohane, Sean Griffin, and John R. Ewell


Past Co-Chairs

2023-2024
Neil Posner
David Zizik

2022-2023
John Bonnie
Neil Posner

2021-2022
Neil Posner
John Bonnie

2021-2022

Neil Posner
John Bonnie


2019-2020
Neil Posner
John Bonnie

2018-2019
Douglas McIntosh
Neil Posner
John Bonnie

2017-2018
John Bonnie
Douglas McIntosh
Neil Posner

2016-2017
Douglas McIntosh
Neil Posner
Jim Sutterfield

2015-2016
Douglas McIntosh

Jim Sutterfield
Neil Posner

2014-2015
Douglas McIntosh
Jim Sutterfield
Neil Posner